Probation Reform: Freeing the Innocent

History:

Only two states had probation systems as broken as that of Rhode Island. Although the US justice system emphasizes the importance of due process, a fair trial, and the presumption of innocence, previously, Rhode Island law did not provide these basic rights to people on probation. As a result, innocent people were imprisoned. When a person on probation was charged with a new crime, they could be sent to prison for violating probation. Even if they were not found guilty of the new charge, they remained in prison for long periods of time for the violation.

OpenDoors advocated for sensible reform to require those accused of a new crime to be released from prison if they were found not guilty or if the charges in the new case were dismissed.  In 2010, the legislature finally succeeded in passing this key probation reform.

Details:

Those who may qualify to be considered for release must petition the court.  The judge ultimately has to make a finding in each case.  If you think you might qualify, contact the attorney that represented you.

In order to petition the court, one of the following must apply:

• you have been found not guilty by a jury

• the grand jury has filed a no true bill

• the judge has dismissed the case for lack of evidence

• the state AG has dismissed the case for lack of evidence

Related Reports

Stronger Than Their Walls

Released: June 2009, (DVD, Vimeo, youtube)

Status of Relevant Legislation: PASSED

This documentary follows the story of several men who were imprisoned even though the charges for which they were sent to prison were dropped or they were found innocent. The families of these imprisoned men take the issue to the Rhode Island Statehouse, where they tell their stories in an effort to reform the law.

Released: July 2010

Status of Relevant Legislation: PASSED

This fact sheet can help you learn more about the probation reform and how it might affect you.

Released: June 2008

Status of Relevant Legislation: PASSED

When someone on probation is accused of a new crime, the allegations are often addressed in a violation hearing, where the burden of proof is significantly lower than in a standard criminal trial.

In Rhode Island, those charged with committing a crime while on probation go straight back to the ACI, and stay there—even if acquitted of the later charges.